Legal opinion on Indian law for foreign lenders, investors and companies
If you are outside India and a deal touches an Indian company, someone will probably ask for an Indian-law opinion. It is a standard document in cross-border transactions, and these are the questions it usually has to settle.
Is the Indian party allowed to do this, and did it do it properly?
The opinion confirms that the company exists, has the power to enter the transaction and has taken the approvals it needs. Under the Companies Act, 2013, borrowing, giving security, making loans and investments, and issuing securities can each need a board resolution, a special resolution of shareholders, or both. Skipping a step can leave a signed document open to challenge.
Does exchange control allow it?
The Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 and the rules under it govern foreign investment, foreign loans and cross-border payments. Which route applies (automatic or government approval), whether sector limits and pricing rules are met, and what has to be reported to the RBI afterwards are all part of the opinion. One example is Press Note 3 of 2020, which requires government approval for investment from countries that share a land border with India.
Is the document stamped?
Stamp duty in India is mostly a state matter, and the rate depends on the document and the state. Under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and the state laws, an unstamped or under-stamped agreement is not void, but it cannot be admitted in evidence until the duty and a penalty are paid. We check stamping because it is the sort of defect nobody notices until the day you need to enforce.
Can you enforce it in India?
A judgment from a court in a reciprocating territory, which includes the UK, Singapore and the UAE, can be executed in India as if it were an Indian decree under Section 44A of the Code of Civil Procedure. A judgment from a non-reciprocating country, such as the United States, generally means filing a fresh suit in India on the judgment. Foreign arbitral awards are enforced under Part II of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which gives effect to the New York Convention. Which route you are on changes the time, the cost and the risk, and an enforceability opinion explains it for your contract.
A foreign lender or investor usually also wants to know that the opinion can be relied on. Reliance by named third parties is something we agree at the start, in writing, so there are no surprises later.